The Cult of Melinda

The gAyTM is closed! No gay rights, no gay $$$!

Tuesday, June 02, 2009

Fellow Pro-Choicers...

Please stop making us look stupid.

You think it's clever to challenge pro-lifers with miscarriage and spontaneous abortion as some sort of counterpoint to their opposition to induced abortion. Often, you'll snicker and pat yourself on the back after making this argument because you're sure that the stunned look on their faces is proof of your ideological and rhetorical victory. You're wrong. It's not clever. You deserve neither to snicker nor to pat yourself on the back. That stunned look is not proof of victory but a response to the complete stupidity that is your argument. Look at any intelligent pro-choicer's face after you've made that argument and you'll probably see the same stunned look.

You see, whether you like it or not, there is a difference between miscarriage/spontaneous abortion and induced abortion just as there is a difference between dying of natural causes and dying due to some action on the part of another human being, be it manslaughter or murder or self-defense. There is a HUGE difference. To say that pro-lifers have to be opposed to G-d or nature's creation of miscarriage in order to be ideologically consistent is just ridiculous. That's the equivalent of saying that a person can't be ideologically opposed to murder or manslaughter if they're not also ideologically opposed to dying of old age.

So, please stop making that argument. You've embarassed the movement enough.


Blogger Stacey said...

I'm also a fan of "what about ectopic pregnancies?"

7:04 PM  
Blogger Melinda Barton said...

That really ticks me off too. I'm pro-Choice but reluctantly. I'm mainly a make them legal and rare kind of person. But some of the people who make arguments like this make me wish there was a third option so I wouldn't have to be associated with their stupidity.

2:39 PM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home